Criminal Law Web



Mental States Comparative Chart


Canada (per Canadian Criminal Code)

"Subjective" Fault
- Intent(ion)
- Purpose
- Wilfulness
- Knowledge
- Wilful Blindness
- Recklessness
- [Malicious]
- [Dishonest]
- [Fraudulent]
- [Corrupt]

"Objective" Fault
- Negligence

Canada (per Draft Code, LRCC)

Purpose
Recklessness
Negligence











Model Penal Code

Purpose
Knowledge
Recklessness
Negligence


NY Penal Law

Intention
Knowledge
Recklessness
Criminal Negligence

Germany (per German Criminal Code, StGB)

Vorsatz (intention)
- Absicht (purpose)
- Wissentlichkeit (knowledge)

Fahrlässigkeit (negligence)

[Leichtfertigkeit (gross negligence?)] (e.g., § 97 StGB)
[Rücksichtslosigkeit (recklessness?)] (§ 315c StGB)
[Böswilligkeit (malice?)] (§ 225 StGB)







Germany (jurisprudence)

Vorsatz/dolus (intention)
- dolus directus
= 1st degree: Absicht (purpose)
= 2d degree: direkter Vorsatz (knowledge)
- dolus eventualis (oblique/conditional intention)

Fahrlässigkeit/culpa (negligence)
- Conscious (advertent) culpa
- Unconscious (inadvertent) culpa